The man at table six had already put on his coat when he called me over and asked for his dessert back.
“You sent it away untouched,” I said.
“I know. Is it still possible?”
At the booth behind him, a woman stopped halfway through zipping her purse. I recognized her from the hardware store and from six months of Wednesday nights at our diner. Her name was Marcy Bell. His was Everett Hale. They always asked for separate checks, even when they shared fries.
That night, they’d ordered one slice of cherry pie and two forks. Then Marcy had slid a folded twenty under her coffee cup, and Everett had pushed the pie away.
I brought it back from the counter. Everett waited until I set it down.
“How much extra does she usually leave you, June?”
Marcy looked up. “You can ask me that.”
“I did. Last Wednesday. You told me to go warm up the car.”
A couple at the counter went quiet. I’d spent enough years waiting tables to know when people were listening. They got very interested in stirring their coffee.
“I don’t discuss one customer’s bill with another,” I said.
Everett nodded, but his ears had gone red. “I’m sorry. You shouldn’t be in this.”
I took a step away. Then Marcy said, “He thinks I’m making up for him.”
Everett pulled his check out of his coat pocket. A dollar was clipped to it.
“I can afford soup and a dollar,” he said. “If that’s a problem, we can meet somewhere else.”
“Where?” Marcy asked. “The library closes at six. You won’t come to my house because you say my front steps are a lawsuit.”
“They are.”
She almost smiled. Then she looked down at her hand, still resting on the twenty.
“The first night you didn’t come, I stayed eight minutes,” she said. “That was about all I could stand by myself.”
Everett sat back down.
I remembered that night. Marcy had ordered two coffees out of habit. When she left, she’d slipped me a twenty because I’d been sitting across from her for most of those eight minutes, listening to her tell me how she’d nearly called her late husband to ask what kind of windshield wipers to buy.
“I leave extra when June sits with me,” Marcy said. “She’s on the clock. I know what it’s like to have somebody take up your time and forget you’re working.”
“Then why do you do it when I’m here?”
“Because sometimes you go warm up the car and she sits with me anyway.”
Everett turned his coffee cup by the handle. After a minute he asked, “Do you want me to quit warming up the car?”
“In February? Good Lord, no.”
He laughed first. Marcy followed, quietly enough that the couple at the counter could go back to their coffee.
When I came around with the pot, Everett had cut the pie straight down the middle. He’d given Marcy the half with more crust. She’d been picking the crust off his plate for six months.
The following Wednesday, Everett was already at table six when Marcy walked in. She put her gloves on the seat beside her and ordered two coffees.
He let her. When the pie came, he paid for it.










