/My Mother’s Name Was on a Bench I Was Paid to Remove

My Mother’s Name Was on a Bench I Was Paid to Remove

The last bench on my list had my mother’s name on it.

I’d already taken out three of the four bolts when I brushed a clump of wet leaves off the seat and saw the brass plaque.

FOR CELIA ROWE
WHO ALWAYS LEFT ROOM

I sat down hard enough to learn what the fourth bolt was for.

“You all right?” my apprentice, Mateo, called from the truck.

“Hand me the work order.”

The city was replacing the wooden benches at the old ferry landing. Anyone who’d paid for a dedication had thirty days to claim their plaque. According to the work order, somebody had called about this one twice. She was coming at noon.

It was eleven forty-three.

My mother left when I was six. I remember her cutting my bangs over the kitchen sink and telling me to hold still around the ears. I remember her making popcorn in a saucepan and letting me eat the burned pieces because I liked them. I don’t remember saying goodbye. One afternoon my aunt Ruth picked me up from school, and she kept picking me up until I was old enough to drive myself.

Ruth answered questions the way she answered the phone at her appliance repair shop. She gave you the information she had and got back to work.

“Was she sick?”

“Sometimes.”

“Did she know where we lived?”

“Yes.”

“Do you think she’ll come back?”

“I don’t know, Nell. Do you want me to sit with you awhile?”

Sometimes I said yes. Sometimes I wanted her to go away because she was the person I could make go away.

I called her from the landing.

“Did you know there was a bench for Celia down here?”

Ruth was quiet for a moment. In the background I heard the radio she kept on at the shop.

“Is the plaque still on it?” she asked.

Read Also:  I Opened The Locket My Ex Gave Me—And What Was Hidden Inside Made My Blood Run Cold

“I’m looking at it.”

“Can you leave that one until tomorrow?”

“We have a truck coming for the lumber at two. Who’s picking it up?”

“I am,” she said.

She arrived at noon with a canvas grocery bag folded under her arm. She’d changed out of her work shirt. I noticed because the only other time she’d done that in the middle of a weekday was for my driving test.

“You bought her a bench?”

“I paid for the plaque. The ferry crew built the bench.”

“When?”

“Fourteen years ago.”

I was thirty-one. Fourteen years ago I’d been seventeen, working Saturday mornings at Ruth’s shop. I’d eaten lunch with her on an overturned washing machine for most of that summer. My mother’s name hadn’t come up once.

Ruth looked out at the empty landing. “This is where we met.”

I thought she meant when they were girls. Then she said, “First Sunday of the month. We did it for nearly five years.”

I put the work order down. “You told me you didn’t know if she’d come back.”

“I didn’t. I knew she’d come here.”

The first time Celia called, Ruth said, I’d been twelve. She wanted to know if I still sang in the school choir. Ruth told her I’d quit because the director had made us learn a song about dental hygiene. My mother laughed so hard she had to put the phone down.

After that, they met at the landing. Celia brought coffee in a thermos. Ruth brought news about me. My mother learned that I’d broken my wrist, that I’d made the honor roll, and that I wanted to build things for a living. She asked to come to my high school graduation. Ruth told her she could, provided she called me first.

Read Also:  He Married Me for My Money—Then My Mother’s Last Wish Turned the Tables

“Did she?”

“You would remember if she had,” Ruth said.

I hated her for saying it so gently.

“Why didn’t you give me a choice?”

“At first she asked me to wait until she had a place of her own. Then until she had steady work. I saw how much you missed her, and I kept thinking I could get her to follow through if I gave her another month.” Ruth rubbed a thumb along the folded edge of the bag. “By the time I knew she wouldn’t, I’d gotten pretty good at keeping it from you.”

“Is she alive?”

“Yes. The last I heard, she was in Toledo. That was three years ago.”

From the truck came the soft clatter of Mateo sorting sockets that had already been sorted. I was grateful to him for finding something to do.

“Why does it say she always left room?” I asked.

“That’s what our dad used to say about her. She’d move over for anybody. Down here there was an older man named Frank who came to watch the ferries after his wife died. Celia used to put her bag on the ground when she saw him coming. Most days he never said a word.” Ruth looked down at the plaque. “I liked watching her do that. I missed being her sister.”

I’d never considered that Ruth might have wanted something from those Sundays, too.

She offered me Celia’s last phone number. I took it and asked her to go home. Then I removed the plaque, slipped it into her grocery bag and put the bag in the cab.

Two nights later, I called. My mother answered on the fourth ring. After I told her who I was, I could hear her turn down a television.

“Ruth said you wanted to come to my graduation,” I said.

“I bought a blue dress for it.”

Read Also:  The Secret Note in Her Lunchbox Turned Out to Be a Silent Cry for Help

I waited. Normally, when someone was uncomfortable, I rushed in with something they could say yes to. I wanted to hear what she’d say if I gave her time.

“I kept thinking about you standing there with your friends,” she said at last. “I thought you might ask me where I’d been, right in front of everybody. And I couldn’t think of an answer I could stand to give you.”

“You could tell me now.”

“I could try.”

We talked for twenty minutes. Most of it was awkward. She asked if I still built furniture. I told her I’d started out making cabinets and now spent a lot of time persuading people to stop painting over screws. That got the laugh Ruth had told me about. I’d forgotten it started with a little snort.

When she asked if she could call on Sunday, I gave her a time. She called six minutes early. I let it ring once while I finished buttering my toast, then picked up.

The following Saturday, I took the plaque to Ruth’s shop. She was out back eating lunch on an old washing machine, her sandwich balanced on a repair manual. I hadn’t been there in months. We’d both been taking turns saying we were busy.

I handed her the bag.

“Did you talk to her?” she asked.

“Twice.”

She nodded and drew breath to ask something else.

“I’ll tell you about it when I’m ready,” I said. “What did I miss around here?”

Ruth moved the manual to her lap, and I sat down beside her. She unwrapped the other half of her sandwich and handed it to me. It was egg salad with too much mustard, the same sandwich she’d packed me for school. I’d spent years telling her she used too much mustard.

This time I asked if there was any more.